This song is really good and well performed too. I like the way you did the vocals (and yes, the reverb too), they have a vintage feel. I think the instruments are recorded very well too.
My only critic is: the guitar is very pressing/ too hard compressed. Especially the lower snares are coming in very hard. I think this song will sound better with a lighter, more relaxed guitar sound, giving the beautiful vocals more space.
But again: very well done!