I have a drive like that, I think it’s an HP lightscribe - that’ll be the second one of those that went south quickly - never again.
I’m sure the new drive will solve your problem. 
(I still have an “antique” Pentium PC running Windows 95 or 98, with a tape drive as well as 5-1/4 floppy in the studio. I keep it primarily though for a 6502 microprocessor emulation software, I still need for programming an even older synth. 
)