Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Discussions about our next-generation scoring application, Dorico.

Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Postby Romanos401 » Thu Jun 15, 2017 4:14 am

Hi all-- I'm sorry to veer a little bit off of topic (ie- Dorico specific things) however this is such a thriving forum I thought it might be nice to have a thread specifically devoted to people who would like second opinions on notation practices. I do not mean to abuse the scope of this forum or to ignore the many other great notation-specific forums out there, but for non-scientific things, it would still be nice for anyone who might benefit from it, or is simply new to the world of notation and engraving. (Besides, lets face it... we all love Dorico because of how pretty it can make a score! :P ) To the Steinberg moderators, if you decide to pull this thread down I won't be offended in the slightest.

All of that out of the way, I'm working on a piano composition right now. I am an organist by trade and so I'm quite used to staring down dense counterpoint. As a result, I'm fairly certain that the notation I'm willing to put up with is a bit skewed compared to many pianists. I know that the goal of notation is always to achieve the greatest clarity. Some pianist-composers simply use pedal markings to create the sonorous effect without notating as strictly. My organist brain won't permit that, and I want to make sure that when there is a voice, it is accounted for at least within the measure. As this part of the score has the melody wrapped up with a flowing sub-texture, I suddenly was befuddled a bit as to best practice. So here we go, time to vote!

A was my initial entry. Again, this made sense to my organist brain but it looked a little dense to me. B is with split beaming. C is when I switched the voices and D is when I split the beams again. My guess, seeing all 4 side-by-side is D, but I am torn between splitting and not splitting the beaming across the measure. A measure-length beam creates a certain continuity in my mind, but it simultaneously obscures the contour of the passage which is also very important. (And I wont even mention the permutations with cross-staff beaming for the right hand.... :shock: )

Screen Shot 2017-06-14 at 9.55.55 PM.png
A, B, C, or D?
(170 KiB) Not downloaded yet

Cheers!
Romanos401
Junior Member
 
Posts: 182
Joined: Fri Dec 02, 2016 4:18 am
Has thanked: 222 times
Been thanked: 64 times

Re: Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Postby Robby Poole » Thu Jun 15, 2017 5:07 am

I'm not a pianist, but I would vote for D. It seems the less cluttered, and makes the most sense. C is my number 2. I would do anything possible to avoid A or B.

Robby
Dorico 1.1
Finale (since v2.2), Sibelius (v1.2 through 7.3),
Mac Pro 2.7 GHz 12-core Intel Xeon E5, 64 GB RAM, 1 TB HDD
~ or ~
27" iMac 2.66 GHz Intel Quad Core i5, 4 GB RAM, 1 TB HDD
Robby Poole
Member
 
Posts: 333
Joined: Sat Jul 09, 2016 3:35 am
Location: Albuquerque, New Mexico USA
Has thanked: 297 times
Been thanked: 102 times

Re: Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Postby JackvL » Thu Jun 15, 2017 7:52 am

D
JackvL
New Member
 
Posts: 20
Joined: Wed Oct 26, 2016 1:27 pm
Has thanked: 0 time
Been thanked: 4 times

Re: Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Postby ReRei » Thu Jun 15, 2017 8:38 am

I am a pianist.

I would also prefer D.
ReRei
Junior Member
 
Posts: 68
Joined: Fri Apr 21, 2017 8:53 pm
Has thanked: 14 times
Been thanked: 5 times

Re: Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Postby LAE » Thu Jun 15, 2017 9:08 am

I would also go for D or C, just like you I cannot decide whether it is better with the splitted beam or not. Maybe it is a question of frasing? In that case I guess I would prefer C.

Another way to do it:


Image

The first bar might not be to your liking, but to me it makes the melody line come out clearer.
However, In the second bar I think it is much better to cross the staff on the second note, because it will show the direction of the line better.
Attachments
notes.PNG
(25.8 KiB) Not downloaded yet
Dorico 1.0.30
Finale 2014.5
Windows 10
LAE
Junior Member
 
Posts: 150
Joined: Tue Dec 06, 2016 9:01 pm
Has thanked: 21 times
Been thanked: 23 times

Re: Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Postby LeifG » Thu Jun 15, 2017 9:16 am

D. The melody line consistently facing upwards and the beaming clearly showing the beat pattern.

I'm a pianist with a lot of sight reading experience.
LeifG
Junior Member
 
Posts: 74
Joined: Thu Mar 09, 2017 9:15 am
Has thanked: 4 times
Been thanked: 23 times

Re: Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Postby Rob Tuley » Thu Jun 15, 2017 10:57 am

D, but why do you beam all the 16th-notes together in bar 2? Two separate groups of 4, without the apparent cross-staff beaming, and stems down for the second group of four, would be easier to read IMO.
Rob Tuley
Member
 
Posts: 559
Joined: Fri May 20, 2016 12:41 am
Has thanked: 19 times
Been thanked: 250 times

Re: Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Postby Romanos401 » Thu Jun 15, 2017 6:16 pm

LAE-- I didn't consider doing that way although I might now that I see it. I had kept it as one motion and as I play it I'm simply stressing the particular melody notes to pull them out even though it is a fluid single motion of the right hand. I could practically make it all 16ths and just put accents or tenutos over those notes too. That's how I ended up with A. I initially jotted out all the 16ths since that's what I played and then I realized I needed to stress the melody and could account for it via a second voice.

Rob, that was just the default way that Dorico had linked them and I didn't separate partly due to the cross-staff nature of the gesture so I wanted it to be clear that it was all LH material. I can definitely break it though and I plan on adding straight lines to indicate the line as it crosses barlines to the top staff.
Romanos401
Junior Member
 
Posts: 182
Joined: Fri Dec 02, 2016 4:18 am
Has thanked: 222 times
Been thanked: 64 times

Re: Which Notation is Clearest? Share your ideas!

Postby Marc-André Roberge » Thu Jun 15, 2017 11:06 pm

D, or maybe C, but never A or B.
Windows 8.1 Enterprise, Windows 10 Home; Sibelius 6.2, Dorico 1.0.30
Marc-André Roberge
New Member
 
Posts: 3
Joined: Thu Oct 13, 2016 4:32 am
Has thanked: 14 times
Been thanked: 1 time


Return to Dorico

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Rob Tuley, Romanos401 and 7 guests