I can’t comment on how to get that exact sound as I don’t know how to get it but…
My 1st advice is to make sure your guitar audio is located on a stereo audio track. Not on a mono audio track. Some stereo effects don’t work (sound) quite right when inserted on a mono audio track. If on a mono track just create a stereo track and drag the audio to it. The file is still mono but, the stereo effect will work better.
For the reason above… I never record any audio on a mono audio track.
Regards 